Two Riverhead Decisions Address Cannabis Dispensary Zoning in New York
A recent New York Appellate Division decision, Matter of 1086 OCR, LLC v. Town of Riverhead Zoning Board of Appeals, addressed the issue of preemption when it comes to a municipality’s ability to regulate adult-use cannabis dispensaries.
The Court held that a provision in the Town’s zoning code requiring dispensaries to be located 1,000 feet from a school was preempted by New York’s Marijuana Regulation and Taxation Act (MRTA), which requires a 500-foot distance between dispensaries and schools. The Town’s restriction was greater than the restriction provided under state law, and therefore, state law controls and the local provision was preempted.
In a companion case decided the same day, Matter of Tink & E. Co., Inc. v. Town of Riverhead, the Second Department found that Riverhead’s 1,000-foot residential setback did not violate the uniformity requirement under Town Law § 262. The Court determined that the Town had a reasonable basis for allowing exceptions for properties along certain commercial corridors.
In the Tink case, the Court also upheld the Zoning Board of Appeals’ denial of a use variance for the dispensary, noting that the applicant had created her own hardship by signing a lease for a property where a dispensary could not operate without a variance. This is an important consideration for prospective cannabis applicants and highlights the importance of reviewing local zoning requirements and obtaining necessary variances before committing to a location.
The Tink case also raises questions about competing dispensary applications. Under the Town’s 2,500-foot separation requirement between dispensaries, a competing applicant located just 1,607 feet away could complicate or potentially preclude approval of another application. This raises practical questions for municipalities: How should competing applicants be prioritized, and how can municipalities ensure a fair review process?
Cuddy + Feder attorneys continue to monitor developments in New York’s cannabis laws and regulations and their implications for clients navigating licensing, zoning, and land use requirements. For additional information, explore our related articles and client alerts, or contact Kristen Motel or Hailey Pedicano.
Related Articles and Client Alerts